Short answer
For most people, there’s no real difference: both describe a soft toy with a fabric covering and a soft filling. Where people do distinguish them, “stuffed animal” is the traditional term and focuses on animal-shaped toys. “Plush” or “plushie” highlights the soft pile fabric and is also used for characters, objects and collectible designs. Opinions differ, and there isn’t an official rule.
Fabric
“Plush” is the name of a fabric with a soft, raised pile. A plush toy, in the narrow sense, is made from it. “Stuffed animal” says nothing about the fabric. A felt rabbit or a cotton bear is a stuffed animal, even though it’s not plush fabric. In everyday speech, though, many people call any cuddly stuffed toy a plushie, regardless of fabric. For the fabrics themselves, see a guide to plush fabrics.
Shape and subject
A stuffed animal is, by name, an animal. A plush toy can be anything: a cartoon character, a piece of food, a planet or an abstract creature. This is one reason “plush” has become the more flexible word. Online communities tend to say that branded, game or anime items are plushies, while classic unbranded animal toys are stuffed animals, but this is a tendency and not a rule.
Filling
Both are typically filled with polyester fiberfill. Neither term specifies filling. Some are filled with wool, cotton or pellets, and the terms apply equally to them. For a comparison of fillings, see choosing stuffing for stuffed animals.
Slang and community use
“Plushie” and “stuffie” are casual and common among collectors and online communities. “Stuffed animal” sounds more traditional and is often used by parents and in shops. In the UK and Australia, “soft toy” is more common than either. For that comparison, see soft toy vs plush toy.
Why “plushie” caught on
It’s short and friendly, it covers non-animal shapes, and it’s associated with collecting and fandom. As more toys are based on characters, and as online sharing of toys has grown, the word has spread. It also helps that the word emphasizes the soft, huggable fabric that people like about these toys.
Does it matter when buying or making?
Not really. When shopping, either word will find the same products. When making your own, you just need to decide on a fabric and a shape. If you want a classic plush feel, choose a pile fabric; if you want something simpler, felt or fleece will do. For a definition of the term, see what is meant by plush toy, and for a hands-on start, our guide to making plushies.