Materials and Supplies

Choosing Stuffing for Stuffed Animals and Soft Toys

Compare polyester fiberfill, cluster fill, cotton, wool, pellets and household substitutes to pick the right stuffing for plush and crochet toys.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Polyester fiberfill
  3. Cluster fiberfill
  4. Natural fillings
  5. Foam and poly pellets
  6. Is cotton stuffing better than polyester?
  7. Best filling for crochet and knitted toys
  8. Alternatives and substitutes
  9. What can I crochet without stuffing?
  10. How to make a stuffed animal soft again
  11. Safety and care
  12. Where to buy filling

The short answer

For most plush and soft toys, polyester fiberfill is the standard choice. It is inexpensive, light, springy and generally machine washable. Other fillings are useful for specific goals: natural fibers for an all-natural toy, foam for firmness, pellets for weight, and household scraps when you only need a small amount or are making something decorative.

The right filling depends on who the toy is for, how it should feel (squishy, firm or weighted), how it will be washed, and how it is made (sewn fabric or crocheted).

Polyester fiberfill

This is what is inside most store-bought stuffed animals and dolls. It is sold in bags as loose fluffy fiber, often labeled with brand names such as Poly-Fil, or simply as toy stuffing.

Pros: inexpensive, widely available, light, doesn’t absorb much moisture, and usually holds up in the wash.

Cons: it is a synthetic plastic fiber, it can clump with heavy use, and loose strands can poke through loosely stitched fabric.

Tips for using it well:

Cluster fiberfill

Cluster fiberfill is polyester fiber formed into small, rounded puffs. It tends to feel lofty and resist clumping, and it is popular for pillows and for toys with a soft, squishy feel. It can be easy to push into small spaces. In loosely stitched crochet, the small clusters can sometimes work their way out between stitches, so test a little first.

Natural fillings

  • Cotton: soft and breathable, but heavier and denser than polyester, and it can hold moisture and take a long time to dry.
  • Wool: a resilient natural fiber. It tends to felt if washed in the machine, so wool-filled toys are typically spot-cleaned.
  • Kapok: a light, silky plant fiber from seed pods. It is a flammable material and tends to break down and lose fluff over time, so many makers avoid it in children’s toys.
  • Corn fiber and other plant-based fibers: sold as eco-friendly alternatives to polyester. Check each product’s care and safety information.
  • Buckwheat hulls and similar seeds or grains: firm and moldable, used more for heavy pillows or sensory items than for ordinary plush. They are not washable and can attract moisture.

Foam and poly pellets

  • Shredded foam gives a denser, more supportive fill. Some makers mix it with fiberfill to get a firm but not rock-hard result.
  • Poly pellets are small plastic beads used to add weight, for example to a toy that should sit or drape. Contain them in an inner pouch so they can’t escape. See our guide to making a weighted stuffed animal with poly pellets.

Is cotton stuffing better than polyester?

Neither is better in every situation. Cotton appeals to people who want a natural material, but it is heavier, takes longer to dry and may mat down. Polyester is lighter, springier and easier to wash and dry, which is why it dominates commercial toys. If a natural fill matters to you, consider wool or another natural fiber and plan on gentle care.

Best filling for crochet and knitted toys

Amigurumi and other crocheted toys use the same fiberfill, but there are a few extra considerations:

  • Tight stitches (a smaller hook than the yarn calls for) help keep stuffing from showing through.
  • Dark yarn can show white stuffing through gaps. Using dark filling or a layer of fabric inside can help, though many crocheters simply stitch tightly.
  • Stuff firmly. Crocheted toys often look better and keep their shape when they are filled more densely than a sewn toy would be.
  • Stuff as you go, before closing the final rounds, and use a tool to reach into small parts.

For toys with a fabric-like softness, polyester fiberfill is the usual recommendation.

Alternatives and substitutes

If you don’t have toy stuffing on hand, these can work, with caveats:

  • Fabric scraps or old t-shirts, cut into small pieces. Inexpensive and clean, but the toy ends up denser and heavier and may feel lumpy.
  • Yarn scraps, cut into small pieces. Fine for small toys or ornaments.
  • Stuffing from an old pillow or toy. This can work, especially if the filling is clean and in good condition. Check older material for dust, odors and wear.
  • Cut-up plastic bags or packing material. These give a crinkly or bulky fill and are better for decorative items than for toys meant to be hugged, and they are generally not suitable for babies, young children or pets.

Can you use pillow stuffing for toys? Often yes, if it is polyester fiberfill in good condition, and clean it first. Pillow stuffing made of down or feathers is not a good choice for toys because of the sharp quills and allergy potential.

Avoid dry food such as rice or beans in toys for young children or pets. They can attract moisture or pests and are a hazard if the seam breaks.

What can I crochet without stuffing?

Flat or lightweight projects usually need no filling: coasters, wall hangings, blankets, flat appliqués, small ornaments and lightweight wearables. A toy made of a thick, stiff yarn or a tightly worked firm fabric can also hold some shape without much fill, but most 3D toys look better stuffed.

How to make a stuffed animal soft again

A flat or lumpy toy can often be revived:

  • Fluff and knead the toy by hand to break up clumps.
  • Wash it, if the care label allows, then dry it thoroughly on a low setting or air dry. Surface-wash only if you’re unsure.
  • Add a little fresh stuffing through a small opening in a seam, then close it with a ladder stitch.
  • Brush the pile of a plush fur toy gently to lift the fibers.

For more detail, see how to puff up a plushie.

Safety and care

  • For babies and children under three, avoid loose small fillings and make sure seams are secure.
  • Wash filling before use only if it’s a washable type, and let it dry completely before stuffing.
  • If you plan to sell toys, check the labeling and material requirements for children’s products where you sell.

Where to buy filling

Craft and fabric stores, big-box retailers and online sellers all stock fiberfill. Buying a larger bag is usually more economical per unit if you make toys regularly. Check our supplies guide for the rest of what you’ll need.

The complete guide to materials and supplies

Soft Toy Making Supplies and Materials Guide
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →

Cloth Doll Making for Beginners

A beginner's guide to making a cloth doll: the materials to buy, how to choose a free pattern, the basic sewing steps, and where to go for faces, hair and clothes.

Cloth Dolls 5 min read