Short answer
In everyday use, a soft toy and a plush toy are usually the same kind of object: a fabric toy filled with soft stuffing. “Soft toy” is the broader and more general term, common in British and Commonwealth English. “Plush toy” or “plushie” is more informal and is often used for toys made from plush fabric, or for character and collector designs. There isn’t a strict official dividing line, and people use the words interchangeably.
Soft toy
“Soft toy” describes almost any toy with a fabric exterior and soft filling, whatever the material or style. A felt rabbit, a fleece bear and a fluffy faux-fur dog could all be called soft toys. The phrase is especially common in the UK, Australia and other Commonwealth countries, and in toy shops and craft books there.
Plush toy
“Plush” refers in the first place to a type of fabric: a soft textile with a raised pile that is longer than velvet. A plush toy is, strictly speaking, one made from that fabric. In practice, “plush toy” and “plushie” are used more loosely for any cuddly stuffed toy, and they’re especially popular for stylized characters, mascots and collectibles. See what is meant by plush toy for more on the definition.
Side by side
- Scope: Soft toy is the broader umbrella. Plush toy is somewhat narrower in origin, but loosely used.
- Fabric: Plush implies a pile fabric. Soft toy doesn’t specify one.
- Tone: Soft toy is neutral and traditional. Plushie is casual, and common online and among collectors.
- Subjects: Soft toys tend to be thought of as traditional animals for children. Plushies often include characters from games, anime and shows, as well as food and novelty shapes.
- Region: “Soft toy” is standard in the UK and Australia. “Plush” and “stuffed animal” are more common in North America.
These are tendencies, not rules. Online discussions show people disagree, and many treat the terms as synonyms.
What are soft toys made of?
Most soft toys have an outer fabric and a filling. Typical outer fabrics include plush, minky, fleece, felt, cotton and faux fur. For pile fabrics in particular, see a guide to plush fabrics. The most common filling is polyester fiberfill. Some toys use natural fillings such as wool or cotton, and some add pellets for weight. For a full rundown, see materials needed to make a stuffed animal.
Why stuffed animals are now called plushies
“Plushie” has grown in popularity as collecting, online communities and character merchandise have spread. It’s a short, friendly word that covers animals as well as non-animal shapes, which “stuffed animal” doesn’t. The relationship between “plush” and “stuffed animal” is discussed in what’s the difference between plush and stuffed animal.
Does it matter if you’re making one?
Not really. If you’re sewing your own, what matters is the fabric, the pattern and the stuffing. If you want a plush toy in the strict sense, choose a pile fabric. For a soft toy more generally, felt, cotton or fleece all work. Our beginner’s guide to making plushies covers the process either way.