How safety eyes work
A safety eye has two parts:
- The eye, a plastic or similar head with a short post (shank) on the back, often with ridges or grooves.
- A locking washer (also called a backing), which is pushed onto the post from inside the toy. The ridges let the washer slide on but resist coming off.
When the washer is pressed all the way down against the fabric, the eye is held in place. The name “safety” refers to this locking design, which is meant to be harder to pull out than a sewn-on button. It does not make the eye suitable for every child. See “Are safety eyes actually safe?” below.
What you need
- Safety eyes (with washers) in the size you want
- Pins or stitch markers, to test placement
- Something to make a hole in sewn fabric, such as a sharp awl, or small sharp scissors, if the post won’t pass through the weave
- A tool to help press the washer on, if your fingers can’t. Some people use the back of a spoon or a purpose-made tool
- Your fabric or crocheted piece, not yet fully stuffed
Choosing size and placement
Eye size changes the toy’s personality. Larger eyes spaced widely look younger and cuter. Small eyes placed closer give a more realistic, mature look. If you’re unsure what size you have or need, see how to tell what size safety eyes you have.
Practical tips:
- Pin the eyes (or stick them temporarily with the posts in the fabric) and look at the toy from several angles and from a distance.
- Check that both eyes are the same height and equally far from the center line.
- Mark with a pin or marker and compare against the second eye before you commit. Once a washer is locked on, it is hard to take off without damaging it.
Attaching safety eyes to sewn plush
- Install before sewing the head closed. You need access to the inside to fit the washer.
- Mark the eye position on the right side of the fabric.
- Make a small hole at the mark. On woven or dense fabrics, a sharp awl can push the threads apart without cutting them. With pile fabric, brush the pile away from the hole.
- Push the post through from the front.
- From the inside, slide the washer over the post and press it firmly all the way down until it sits flat against the fabric. You should feel it lock.
- Give the eye a firm tug to test it.
For very stretchy fabric like minky, some makers reinforce the area behind the eye with a small piece of interfacing or felt so the fabric doesn’t tear or distort.
Attaching safety eyes to knitted and crocheted toys
- Place eyes before you stuff and close the toy. Position them between stitches so the post slides through a gap rather than splitting yarn.
- Insert the post from the outside, through the space between two stitches, so the eye sits on the surface.
- Press the washer on from the inside, working through the opening.
- Check the spacing, then stuff. A tightly stuffed head holds the eyes firmly, and a loose one lets them shift.
Many amigurumi makers pin the eyes in and view the head from a few angles before locking them. If you’d prefer to avoid hard eyes altogether, see our guide to embroidering eyes on amigurumi.
Common mistakes
- Locking the washer on before checking placement.
- Not pushing the washer all the way down. If a gap remains, the eye can wobble.
- Using eyes that are too large for the fabric or too heavy for loose stitches.
- Forgetting to leave an opening to reach the inside.
- Cutting a hole bigger than needed, which leaves the post unsupported.
Are safety eyes actually safe?
Safety eyes are designed to be secure, but they’re not risk-free. For babies and children under three, many makers and guidelines recommend embroidered or otherwise sewn-on features instead of any hard eye. A determined child can sometimes pull out a hard eye, especially on older or well-loved toys, and plastic parts can break. If a toy is for a young child, test it by pulling firmly and consider embroidered eyes. Our guide to making a baby-safe stuffed animal covers other features and materials. If you sell toys, check the safety testing and labeling requirements in your market.
How to replace a stuffed animal’s eye
- Check how the eye was attached. A locked safety eye usually has the washer inside the toy.
- Open a seam or a small area near the eye to get inside, taking care not to cut the fabric around the eye hole.
- Remove the old washer, which may require cutting it off with small pliers or snips. Be careful not to damage the surrounding fabric.
- Insert the new eye, with a new washer, and press it firmly.
- Re-stuff if needed and close the opening with a ladder stitch.
If the eye was sewn on (like a button), snip the thread, then sew on a new eye, passing the thread through to the back of the head and anchoring it with a secure knot. For other repairs, see mending stuffed animals.
Alternatives to safety eyes
- Embroidered eyes, using thread or yarn, which suit babies and have no hard parts. See how to embroider eyes on amigurumi.
- Felt eyes, cut and sewn or glued on.
- Printed or fabric eyes, sold by some craft suppliers, or made from fabric scraps.
- Buttons or glass eyes, which suit collector or display pieces and are not appropriate for toys for young children.
Making your own resin eyes
Some makers cast eyes from resin or paint cabochons. If you try it, use products that are intended for crafts, follow the manufacturer’s ventilation and handling instructions, and don’t use handmade resin eyes on toys for young children, since they haven’t been tested the way manufactured safety eyes are.
For the rest of what you need, see our soft toy making supplies guide.