Crochet Plushies

Is knitting or crochet better for stuffed animals?

Is knitting or crochet better for stuffed animals? Compare texture, construction, stuffing, pattern availability and learning curve to pick the right craft.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Texture and feel
  3. Construction
  4. Stuffing and shape
  5. Patterns and learning curve
  6. Which to choose

Short answer

Neither is strictly better. Crochet is more common for stuffed animals and is often considered easier for firm, well-shaped toys. Knitting can produce softer, stretchier toys with a smoother surface. If you already knit, you can make excellent stuffed animals. If you are choosing from scratch and want the widest choice of patterns, crochet is usually the simpler path.

Texture and feel

Crochet fabric is generally denser and a bit bumpy, with less stretch. That is why amigurumi holds its shape and hides stuffing. Knit fabric is generally smoother and more elastic, which can feel softer and floppier. Hook or needle size, yarn choice and how firmly the toy is stuffed all affect the final feel, so these are tendencies, not rules. Opinions among crafters are mixed on which feels softer.

Construction

Most crochet plushies are worked in the round, in a spiral, with a single hook. Shaping happens through increases and decreases, and the toy often comes together with few seams. See our starter guide to crochet plushies.

Knitted toys are made in several ways. Some are knit flat in pieces and seamed, which means more sewing. Others are knit in the round on double-pointed needles or circular needles, which is closer to the crochet approach but needs more needles and some comfort with small circumferences. Shaping is done with increases and decreases in both crafts.

Stuffing and shape

Because crochet is dense with little stretch, it tolerates firm stuffing and keeps features in position. Knit fabric stretches, so heavy stuffing can distort the shape, and stuffing may show through the stitches unless the gauge is tight. Knitters often use a smaller needle and finer gauge for toys. Either way, stuff gradually and check the shape as you go. For judging firmness, see how much stuffing a stuffed animal needs.

Patterns and learning curve

Crochet toy patterns are very widely available, including a large number of designs for no-sew stuffed animals. Knit toy patterns exist in good variety but are generally less abundant. Crochet also needs only one hook, and a mistake can usually be undone by pulling out a few stitches, whereas knitting has many live stitches on the needles at once. Some people find knitting easier to learn, though, because the stitches are uniform. Preference matters more than rules.

Which to choose

  • You want firm, structured toys and lots of patterns: crochet.
  • You want a smooth, soft fabric: knitting may suit you, or you can sew a plush from fabric.
  • You already knit: stay with knitting and try a simple pattern worked in the round.
  • You are brand new to both: many beginners start with crochet for toys, since it uses one tool and tolerates unpicking.

If you are curious about sewn alternatives as well, see amigurumi vs plushie. If you try crochet, learn the magic ring first, since nearly every pattern starts with one.

The complete guide to crochet plushies

Making Crochet Plushies: An Amigurumi Starter Guide
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →